Plato attack on poetry. Plato's Objection to Poetry and Aristotle's Defence 2019-02-03

Plato attack on poetry Rating: 5,3/10 1811 reviews

What are the grounds on which Plato attacks poetry? What is the significance of his attack?

plato attack on poetry

The Epic poet can relate a number of incidents happening simultaneously to a number of persons at a number of places, whereas tragedy presents only that part of the story which is connected with one place, and one set of persons. This is surely a shocker to the sensibilities of any modern reader and his incredulity is not lessened by the peroration with which, a good many pages later, Plato winds up his argument: 'Crucial indeed is the struggle, more crucial than we think - the choice that makes us good or bad - to keep faithful to righteousness and virtue in the face of temptation, be it of fame or money or power, or of poetry- yes, even of poetry. Concentrate instead on his philosophy and his literature. Children tend to imitate the doings of gods and other heroes as told to them by their mothers, they fashion their own conduct on what they read. This error of judgment may arise form: i ignorance Oedipus , ii hasty — careless view Othello iii decision taken voluntarily but not deliberately Lear, Hamlet. Is all of rhetoric bad? There is no airtight barrier between throwing yourself especially habitually into a certain part, body and soul, and being molded by the part; no firm boundary, in that sense, between what happens on and off the stage.

Next

Plato Attack on Poetry Essay

plato attack on poetry

See especially Belfiore 1984, Halliwell 1988, Nehamas 1982; and for a superb summary of the main proposals, Naddaff 2002, 136n8. The subject calls for care. The critics on catharsis by prolonged debated has succeeded only in creating confusion, not in clarifying the concept. Plato's political agenda in The Republic: Is it utopian? Beauty is Plato's example of a Form so frequently for a pair of reasons. According to Plato, poetry is better than philosophy.

Next

Plato's Attack on Poetry

plato attack on poetry

But Aristophanes' influence on Plato extends, as commentators do not always recognize, to the nature of mimêsis. Thus poets were considered to be inferior to the philosophers and orators. Plato's interpreters sometimes play up the passages in which he seems to counter the Republic's anti-poetic comments with hopeful assessments of imitation. All this is most edifying; but it does not appear to be what Aristotle intended. True rhetoric is philosophical discourse. Plato regarded the emotions as undesirable and so advocated their repression; Aristotle, on the other hand, stresses the need for emotional outlets.

Next

Essay about Plato's Attack on Poetry

plato attack on poetry

Now, one thing Plato doesn't talk about is what happens when poetry isn't imitative. But it is not the chief end of tragedy. Their taste for beauty will help them prefer noble deeds over ugly vulgar ones 401b—d, 403c. It is only after Plato has developed his of the that he is able to offer a complete presentation of the vices of poetry. The painter imitated the chair of the carpenter in his picture of chair.

Next

What was Aristotle’s reply to Plato’s objection against poetry? How does he show that is not only pleasant, but also

plato attack on poetry

Although the man's love for Homer prohibits him from possessing expertise, Socrates recognizes how well Ion performs at his job. · the managers or guardians are educated by wholly rational training such as mathematics. Their role is to obey and support the organization's needs by engaging in useful roles in the organization. She argues instead that mimesis has one meaning -- intentional likeness to some other activity or thing -- but that of course the content and context of that intentional likening may differ. One that the majority had taken and one that was less taken. The original departure point lies in those Homeric days when the Greek culture had been one of oral communication. A mimêma however is only ever a copy, not also the copying act that produced it.

Next

Plato's Attack on Rhetoric

plato attack on poetry

Reason is thus kept in abeyance and full sway is given to the emotions. While reading The Republic we can see which side of these paradoxes Plato favors. How does he distinguish Epic and Tragedy? It is philosophy's mission to force them to give an account of themselves, and to examine its soundness. His point of view is entirely utilitarian. Here beauty does better than most other properties at meeting the criteria for Forms and non-Forms. Will inspiration play a role ancillary to imitation, or do the two approaches to poetry have nothing to do with one another? He puts an idea into it.


Next

What was Aristotle’s reply to Plato’s objection against poetry? How does he show that is not only pleasant, but also

plato attack on poetry

Let us discuss it in following point. But what happened to the question about the audience? It is a kind of a disease, for which one has to acquire an antidote. Therefore, we feel, reverence which Aristotle has enjoyed through ages has not gone to him undeserved. Beauty by comparison begins in the domain of intelligible objects, since there is a Form of beauty. He makes the decision not to go with the majority, but to be himself and takes the path less traveled. Goethe was a man of considerable political power.

Next

Literary Criticism

plato attack on poetry

Final Remarks The relationship between philosophy and poetry matters to a philosopher if poetry could conceivably seem a viable alternative to the philosophical way of life. Modern heroes, dies several deaths — passive — not the doer of the action but receiver. According to need, the writer makes use of songs, poetry, poetic dialogue, simple conversation etc is various parts of the play. Hippias had a reputation for the breadth of his factual knowledge. The cosmos is structured in such a way as to support virtue. Plato's model of organization comprised: · the citizens are divided into two classes, rulers and ruled. A rather good man — coming to bad end.

Next

What are the grounds on which Plato attacks poetry? What is the significance of his attack?

plato attack on poetry

The answer to this crucial question constitutes one of the most famous contributions to the topic. If an artist succeeds in pleasing us in aesthetic sense, he is a good artist. Why he objected to poetry? Besides mimêsis Plato sometimes speaks of a mimêma. Still further, Plato's Socrates is not above speaking to his interlocutors rhetorically at times, even sophistically some of his arguments against Thrasymachus in book I of the Republic have been suspected of falling into the latter category, and Socrates' interlocutors are occasionally reported as feeling that he has played some kind of verbal trick on them. The meaning of Catharsis: Let us quote F. We recall that Socrates was put to death in part because he was suspected of being a sophist, a clever rhetorician who twists words and makes the weaker argument into the stronger and teaches others to do the same.

Next

What is Plato's argument against poetry?

plato attack on poetry

Complete with certain magnitude: Epic is vast in its magnitude. The relationship must be built up and maintained during the course of oral recitation. Plato attacks poetry on moral, emotional and intellectual grounds and thus throws light on its uselessness and its corrupt influences. Being a product of inspiration, it effects emotion rather than reason, the heart rather than intellect. An essential premise is that what Book 3 acknowledged as an exception to its critique, namely the imitation of virtuous and thoughtful characters, is not apt to exist. The passions to be moderated are these of pity and fear. Literature is not the photographic reproduction of life in all its totality.

Next